You've done the original Peter Pan animated movie so now I recommend my two favorite Peter Pan adaptations - the 2003 live action Peter Pan and the 1991 adaptation, Hook.
I used to love Hook as a young child! My brother, cousin, and I would watch it on repeat so much we eventually knew most of the lines! Hook is a must!
And the 2003 Peter Pan came out when I was 14 and I absolutely fell in love with it - particularly the two leads playing Peter and Wendy! Their chemistry was off the charts! (They are actually about to play opposite each other in an upcoming romcom and I for one cannot wait to see if they still have that chemistry as adults!)
These are two very differently flavors of the story but I love both!