WELCOME TO THE SORTA STUPID FORUM!
This is where the community hangs out between reactions. Talk shows, movies, anime, and gaming with the crew and other members.
Notifications
Clear all

[Sticky] Question of the Week: What is the worst episode of an otherwise great show?

39 Posts
31 Users
16 Reactions
478 Views
Billy - Gold
Posts: 282
Admin
Topic starter
(@itsbumbs)
Joined: 2 years ago
[#904]

What is the worst episode of an otherwise great show?

Drop your answer below!


38 Replies
7 Replies
Billy - Diamond
(@patreon_41525369)
Joined: 1 year ago

New Member
Posts: 1

Posted by: @itsbumbs

What is the worst episode of an otherwise great show?

 

The Flash: Season 5 or 6, the episode where Cisco temporarily fakes his death and when he undoes that, sends Cicada’s dagger to space instead of another dimension.

Drop your answer below!

 


Reply
Billy - Diamond
(@kyleclairmount5050)
Joined: 1 year ago

New Member
Posts: 1

Posted by: @itsbumbs

What is the worst episode of an otherwise great show?

Drop your answer below!

you guys have reacted to it before but gotta be 'Love and Monsters' from Dr Who series 2

 


Reply
Billy - Diamond
(@patreon_120278004)
Joined: 1 year ago

Active Member
Posts: 2

The fly episode from breaking bad


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Customer
(@william-ashburner-3746)
Joined: 2 years ago

Active Member
Posts: 4

Posted by: @itsbumbs

What is the worst episode of an otherwise great show?

Drop your answer below!

 


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Customer
(@fasttransam98)
Joined: 1 year ago

New Member
Posts: 1

Posted by: @itsbumbs

What is the worst episode of an otherwise great show?

Drop your answer below!

Definitely Roadside Attraction from Gravity Falls

 


Reply
Billy - Diamond
(@el_toro_loco)
Joined: 1 year ago

New Member
Posts: 1

Posted by: @itsbumbs

What is the worst episode of an otherwise great show?

Drop your answer below!

Game of Thrones season 8 episode 6 The Iron Throne

 


Reply
Billy - Diamond
(@aesperi)
Joined: 1 year ago

New Member
Posts: 1

the episode of adventure time with the horse 😭😭 not the deer, the horse. i hated it, so scary 😂


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 38
(@patreon_2378219)
Trusted Member
Joined: 2 years ago

"Chapter Seven: The Lost Sister" is widely considered the worst episode of Stranger Things because it completely halts the momentum of the main story and separates Eleven from the beloved Hawkins ensemble right as the season's climax is heating up. Positioned right after a major cliffhanger in Hawkins, the abrupt shift to a standalone Chicago subplot felt jarring and frustrating for viewers.

🚫 Terrible Narrative Pacing
In Episode 6, the demodogs are invading the lab, and the main characters are in immediate, life-threatening danger. Instead of resolving this tension, Episode 7 pivots to a standalone "bottle episode" structure. This massive detour killed the season's pacing right before the finale.
Aside from Eleven and her lab "sister" Kali (008), the episode introduces a gang of punk outcasts. Many viewers found these new characters to be uninteresting, shallow caricatures who felt like they belonged in a subpar superhero spin-off rather than the established world of Stranger Things.
🏙️ A Radical Change in Tone and Setting
The show's core charm relies on its 1980s small-town Spielbergian atmosphere and the chemistry of its ensemble cast. Moving the action to a gritty, neon-lit Chicago backdrop stripped away the familiar elements fans loved, replacing them with an angsty, revenge-driven tone.
🔄 Minimal Impact on the Immediate Plot
While the episode serves to help Eleven master her powers and realize that Hawkins is her true home, the actual plot progression is minimal. Eleven essentially takes a brief road trip, decides not to commit murder, uses her powers to see that her friends are in danger, and immediately heads back. [1, 2]

Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 7
 John
(@patreon_74801965)
Active Member
Joined: 3 years ago

The great divide from ATLA.

Does there even need an explanation why?


Reply
1 Reply
Billy - Diamond
(@patreon_2378219)
Joined: 2 years ago

Trusted Member
Posts: 38

@patreon_74801965

Flattered and Out-of-Character Behavior
To make the conflict work, the writers exaggerated Team Avatar's traits to a frustrating degree:
  • Katara and Sokka are forced into a petty, aggressive sibling rivalry just to mirror the two feuding tribes. They instantly take sides and act like childish caricatures of themselves.
  • Aang's characterization breaks tradition. Throughout the series, Aang is a figure of immense moral integrity who struggles deeply with honesty and his responsibilities. In this episode, he is suddenly a smooth, expert manipulator.

The biggest flaw for many fans is how Aang resolves the hundred-year-old blood feud. After hearing both sides of the history, Aang realizes neither tribe will compromise. He solves the problem by completely fabricating a lie, telling them he knew the historical figures they worship and that their entire ancient conflict was just a misunderstanding over a children's game. He shows zero remorse for rewriting history, which sends a jarring and uncharacteristic moral message for an Avatar.


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 2
 Kiro
(@patreon_134692113)
New Member
Joined: 1 year ago

Is the question meant as objectively the worst, or one that we disliked in an otherwise great show? I'm a terrible judge of the first, apparently, but for the second case, I'll go with S2E3 of Hazbin, as that episode was just my favorite character stepping on easily visible rake after rake after rake.


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 1
(@patreon_78297422)
New Member
Joined: 3 years ago

the divide in the Avatar the last Air Bender. I know its probably THE most generic answer, but i to this day at 28 can still remember it being played daily and sometimes more then once in my house by my younger siblings that didn't mind the re-runs at there age. the otherwise simplistic and throw a way plot of that episode really made it stand out top me     


Reply
Posts: 1
(@patreon_184311248)
New Member
Joined: 6 months ago

Kinda loose but every episode if steven universe that has Ronaldo just immediately makes me want to skip it. He urks me and annoys me with how childish he acts.


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 3
(@patreon_44010299)
New Member
Joined: 3 years ago

No thinking necessary, steven universe, season 1, episode 5, "Frybo"


Reply
Billy - Gold
Posts: 3
(@etherealdjinn)
New Member
Joined: 1 year ago

"The Desert" - Avatar the Last Airbender

I get and understand how Aang was so upset from losing Appa, but he spent the entire episode being an complete asshole to the rest of the gang and blamed Toph for losing him even when she had no choice if she was gonna save the gang. Not to mention it shows him to be a hypocrite later when he claimed 'All life is sacred'. If he was worried about the 'no killing' rule, he broke that ages ago. And no, I'm not talking about the North Pole. The avalanche at the Northern air temple, the insects in the desert. Hell... he pretty much doomed the sandbenders by destroying their only way of moving around the desert. Just because he doesn't see it, doesn't mean it didn't happened. It really exposes Aang isn't always the person he claims to be. Both him and Katara have the habit of snapping at people when they're upset without caring how they feel.

Katara's worst episode was definitely 'The Southern Raiders' that I called her Jet the entire episode, but it's not a bad episode cause she needed some kind of spiritual journey to get closure. 

But yeah, the desert is the my least favorite.


Reply
1 Reply
Billy - Diamond
(@patreon_2378219)
Joined: 2 years ago

Trusted Member
Posts: 38

@etherealdjinn

Tonal Whiplash from the "Cactus Juice" Comedy
The episode is famous for the meme, "It'll quench ya! It's the quenchiest!" However, many viewers find that Sokka and Momo’s prolonged, drug-tripping hallucination sequence severely undermines the episode's high-stakes survival plot.
Watching Sokka act like a goofy cartoon character directly alongside Aang’s intense, grief-stricken emotional breakdown creates a jarring tonal friction. For a story about dehydration and loss, the misplaced comedy can feel incredibly out of place.

Reply
Billy - Gold
Posts: 1
(@patreon_68771745)
New Member
Joined: 1 year ago

"The Feud!" from Voltron Legendary Defender.


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 5
(@christine1428917)
Active Member
Joined: 3 months ago

Game of Thrones, Season 8, Episode 5: "The Bells."

There are plenty of bad decisions made in GOT, but this entire episode is nothing but bad writing decisions. The characters are shadowy farces of themselves; the only thing the episode shows is spectacle, and will bend character motivations to get to the shock of what happens. I had become more and more disappointed in the show as it went on but this was the episode that just made my not care anymore. Thankfully, there was only one episode left and I knew there was nothing that could be done to save it for me. 

I cant even bring myself to watch the reaction to it here, even though I know the guys' reactions would still be entertaining. 


Reply
4 Replies
Billy - Diamond
(@patreon_2378219)
Joined: 2 years ago

Trusted Member
Posts: 38

@christine1428917

1. Daenerys Targaryen’s "Mad Queen" Turn Felt Unearned
The most controversial moment occurs when King’s Landing rings the bells of surrender, yet Daenerys decides to burn the city and slaughter thousands of innocent civilians anyway. While the series long foreshadowed her ruthless streak, viewers felt the transition from a liberator who protects the innocent to a genocidal tyrant happened far too abruptly over just a couple of episodes, making her villainous pivot feel forced by the writers rather than naturally developed.
 
2. The Annihilation of Jaime Lannister's Redemption Arc
Jaime spent seasons evolving from a man who threw a child out of a window into a honorable, complex hero who fought for the living. This episode abruptly discards years of character growth when he decides to abandon Brienne of Tarth and return to Cersei, stating he never really cared about the innocent people anyway. His story ends with him trapped and crushed by falling rocks, leaving fans deeply unsatisfied.
 
3. A Disappointing End for Cersei Lannister
As one of the show's most calculating, formidable, and long-standing villains, Cersei was expected to face a grand or poetic defeat. Instead, she spends almost the entire final season staring out of a balcony, has zero meaningful agency during the battle, and dies weeping under the rubble of the Red Keep with Jaime.
 
4. Severe Plot Armor and Pacing Issues
The pacing of the final season forced what should have been an entire season's worth of political fallout and tactical warfare into mere minutes.
  • Inconsistent Dragon Logic: Just one episode prior, Euron Greyjoy easily shoots down a dragon with a scorpion crossbow. In "The Bells," Daenerys effortlessly destroys the entire Iron Fleet and all defense systems without Drogon taking a single scratch.
  • Arya's Infinite Survival: Arya Stark spends the episode running through King's Landing, surviving multiple direct building collapses, explosions, and firestorms that kill everyone else around her, leading to criticisms of absurd "plot armor".

5. Anticlimactic Character Disposals

Several major storylines were resolved in ways that felt cheap or neat just to clear the board for the finale:

  • Varys: The master of whispers is caught and executed almost immediately after minimal screen time, a hasty end for one of Westeros' sharpest political minds.
  • Euron Greyjoy: He conveniently washes ashore at the exact same spot as Jaime Lannister for a forced, meaningless beach brawl.
  • Cleganebowl: While highly anticipated, the fiery showdown between the Hound and the Mountain felt detached from the gravity of the city's ongoing massacre.

Reply
Billy - Diamond
(@christine1428917)
Joined: 3 months ago

Active Member
Posts: 5
Billy - Diamond
(@patreon_2378219)
Joined: 2 years ago

Trusted Member
Posts: 38

@christine1428917 watching that episode felt like a weird slap in the face.


Reply
Billy - Diamond
(@christine1428917)
Joined: 3 months ago

Active Member
Posts: 5

@patreon_2378219 

Agreed. And like a "Oh, you still care about this and want to see how things end? Here. Damn. Be grateful there is anything to watch."


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 4
(@patreon_90102036)
Active Member
Joined: 3 years ago

"Roadside Attraction", Gravity Falls. Okay here's the thing, this episode's not even that bad, it's more so about the placement of it. It feels a lot like a season 1 plot, yet it's towards the end of season 2. Also, the whole Candy-Dipper thing wasn't really explored enough for me to feel as invested in it as the writers may have intended. Like I said, it's not a terrible episode, but for Gravity Falls, a show that otherwise has banger after banger episodes back to back, this one's probably the most lackluster. Still some funny bits though lol


Reply
2 Replies
Billy - Diamond
(@patreon_2378219)
Joined: 2 years ago

Trusted Member
Posts: 38

@patreon_90102036

The Double Standard: Mabel, Candy, and Grenda intensely scold Dipper, treating him like a malicious cheater simply for casually talking to girls and getting their numbers to boost his confidence. Viewers noted a frustrating double standard, as Mabel spent the entire series intensely—and sometimes aggressively—chasing random boys without ever facing similar pushback.


Reply
Scott Sandler
(@scott272164)
Joined: 5 months ago

Active Member
Posts: 5

@patreon_90102036 I didn’t understand them putting the protection magic over the house…only to leave town entirely. It’s clearly supposed to be the low-stakes calm before the storm of Dipper and Mabel vs the Future and Weirdmageddon, but Dipper’s so misguided in-story he becomes out of character and it’s uncomfortable.

As for my own contribution, Remembrances from Legend of Korra has good qualities when it finally gets creative creative, but it also has the worst production circumstances. It was the episode that is the linchpin of the big decision that had to be made to save the staff and therefore maintain the final episodes’ quality as much as possible.


Reply
Posts: 1
Customer
(@kartikeya200)
New Member
Joined: 3 years ago

"Profit and Lace" from Deep Space Nine. It's so bad that most of the internet seems to agree that it's not even close, and these are Star Trek fans we're talking about.


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 3
(@tayanap23-gmail-com)
New Member
Joined: 1 year ago

I feel like the one episode that messed up the whole show was when the killed off Derek in grey's anatomy cause from then on it kinda went off the rails I love greys anatomy but come on 


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 1
(@tillerwiller)
New Member
Joined: 1 year ago

Probably a low hanging one but Unhappy Campers, Season 2 Episode 5 of Helluva boss. Having gone back through again it's not as bad as I remember but it's still pretty bad and deserves its status as the worst episode


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 1
(@matthew579088)
New Member
Joined: 5 months ago

Code of Honor in Star Trek TNG


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 23
(@bigdocfan)
Trusted Member
Joined: 3 years ago

Dot and Bubble (Doctor Who)


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 4
Customer
(@william-ashburner-3746)
Active Member
Joined: 2 years ago

Season 7 episode 1 of It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia 


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 1
(@patreon_5818679)
New Member
Joined: 3 years ago

My mind instantly jumps to Buffy Season 4s, “Beer Bad”😭


Reply
Posts: 2
Customer
(@franciscompalacios)
New Member
Joined: 2 years ago

"Last Forever" the series finale for How I Met Your Mother.

A great and hilarious show, that had funny, sad, bittersweet and lovely moments almost in equal parts.
The wrtiers made some multiple seasons storylines about finding the true love, or even better oneself and discover what love is- all that to throw it away in the last episode (actually it was a 2 episodes finale). 

Despite all this, it remains one of my favorite series—one I always find myself rewatching.


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 3
(@patreon_96843780)
New Member
Joined: 2 years ago

Any cartoon that randomly does a beach episode 


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 5
(@sajuukcor)
Active Member
Joined: 2 years ago

Star Trek Voyager. Threshold. Yeaaah.


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 3
(@elizabeth734199)
New Member
Joined: 2 months ago

The ENTIRE season 9 of Scrubs. I try to forget it even happened. 


Reply
Billy - Diamond
Posts: 2
(@joseph_darke7)
New Member
Joined: 1 year ago

Avatar the last airbender - The Great Divide 


Reply
Billy - Gold
Posts: 2
(@joebenny129623)
New Member
Joined: 2 days ago

Lego Ninjago season 2: Wrong place, wrong time. 


Reply
Billy Become a Member