Already a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to access this content.
Msr9272tce
21 minutes
definitely do extended when you can work it in.
Ken
32 minutes
ya i would be down for the extended editions and the hobbit movies
Vegvisir92
1 hour
i would be very interest in his "better solution" for the Oliphant charge......please do a video on his expertise on medieval cavalry warfare
adacor
1 hour
So funny enough, the book that Frodo was writing in at the end is supposed to have been the original manuscript that Tolkien merely translated. Within his own writing, Tolkien placed himself as a sort of linguistic historian who was building out this "missing historical myth" of England. So the Lord of the Rings is more of an autobiography by Frodo, with the accounts of the other perspectives from the other members of the Fellowship.
awesomestudios17
1 hour
I would totally rewatch the series but you should do the extended editions
Vegvisir92
1 hour
With the "nothing to combat dragons" technically those aren't dragons but i guess it still stands, but dragons are basically extinct at the time of LOTR, there might be one or two hanging around but they would not be living where people are, so most nations would not be expecting an attack by dragons or dragonlike beings
Jett
1 hour
Glad you guys enjoyed the Lord of the Rings, hope you guys do watch the extended editions, even if you don’t record them, you should watch them for your own enjoyment. As for the Hibbit movies, I personally enjoyed them, they weren’t as good as the Lord of the Rings, but I find the extended editions are much better than the theatrical versions. So my option is you watch them instead of the theatrical, if you guys decide to watch the hobbit. They aren’t as bad as people make them out to be.
Vegvisir92
1 hour
Konrad Kyeser was a famous German siege engineer who wrote a book about siege warfare
lightning132ttv
1 hour
I think the books go into more detail, but Faramir's father was using a Palantir and it corrupted his mind just enough to lose hope and faith, and to go psycho.
Jam
1 hour
I have a special request... You should look up Elijah Wood (Frodo) and Sean Astin (Samwise) play baldurs gate 3 with the head of larian studio, its such a funny marketed ad video.
LaLa
2 hours
The Hobbit movies would be fine if they hadn't insisted on trying to recreate some of the scenes that make LOTR so memorable, ie: Arwen's entrance > Evangeline showing up to heal the dwarf. For whatever reason the studio wouldn't leave Jackson alone and let The Hobbit just be what it is. HOWEVER, they do add in quite a bit of cannon lore that is happening in the book but wasn't written in the book. One thing Tolkien wished was that he had made The Hobbit darker like his later books. All that said I think they are worth watching and very entertaining. If for no other reason than you get 'Jackson lore' behind why Legolas apparently never runs out of arrows and his glorious campaign of 'Don't touch my stuff!' 🤣
kekkers
2 hours
it's hillarious they thought that the 4 kids at Sam's wedding were his and Rosie's. Like how fast do they think Hobbits grow.
Adam
2 hours
I'm gonna say it- no dinosaurs could fly. Pterosaurs could, but they were a distinct group from dinosaurs.
25redshark
2 hours
Check out the Hobbit movies too!
Kayla
2 hours
https://x.com/DiscussingFilm/status/1864371947389210686 thought this might interest you guys
Y0GE
2 hours
The land the elves are going Is also where the gods live and there are no elves besides aowyn and legolas left in middleearth the rest left and even then legolas only leave when gimli is at the end of his life and legolas also brings him to the undying lands.
Wonderxfull
2 hours
I will happily watch the extended editions with you guys. I can not believe how many scenes were cut out of the theatrical version! Like this edition is great, the story is fantastic and I still cry either way. Loved the reactions. I would be down for The Hobbit trilogy too. I still very much enjoyed The Hobbit movies a lot. It gave me more to experience in this world and so much more backstory. Cannon-ness can be debated later. I think you all would love watching them too, they are fun.
Kelph1
3 hours
So I only recently found you guys on Youtube, and after watching a few of the videos on there, I knew I had to join the Patreon to get access to the whole videos. I feel like watching these is like watching a movie with my buddies, but one where I can sit by and play a video game at the same time and not get badgered about it. Seriously, you guys are great, and I appreciate this kind of content.
jachinsnelson
4 hours
10,000 soldiers of Gondor
6,000 Riders of Rohan
about 4000 reinforcements + ghosts
200,000 orcs and friends
DesertDrifter
4 hours
Elf smiths are just really well good and don't need to start over by melting the sword down all the way
ammy95.
4 hours
High key down for a rewatch with the extended editions
Jonathan
4 hours
Yes please to watching the extended editions!
Cat
4 hours
It was about 200.000 orcs against 10.000 gondorian soldiers and 6.000 riders of Rohan.
MrAlexSan
4 hours
I would gladly watch you rewatch the whole series for the Extended Editions. IMO Fellowship of the Ring and Return of the King extended are the definitive editions of these movies.
2 replies
25redshark
2 hours
Same
lightning132ttv
3 hours
I second this
Chainshada
4 hours
I'm pretty sure the Orlando Bloom video is when they were filming The Hobbit, goofing around between takes.
Ramba_Ya
5 hours
yes rewatch the exrtended woooo
Ajsrippedpantsfromtlc2016
5 hours
We will absolutely rewatch yall rewatch the trilogy extended editions!
Makix217
5 hours
Hell yes, a rewatch with the extended editions?! You sonofabitch, I'm in.
25redshark
5 hours
Yes react to the extendeds!
VexxarSentai
5 hours
Return of the King is a stunning conclusion to the trilogy, Recommend watching the extended editions at some point adds much more depth to the story. hope you guys react to the hobbit
Queer Lynx
6 hours
1000 times yessss please make recording of your extended editions rewatch
1 replies
25redshark
2 hours
This
Andrew
6 hours
Such a shame, you guys didn’t watch the extended edition, but I’m glad you guys enjoyed it. I hope you watch them anyway.
CDMellow
6 hours
i wanna watch you re-watch the whole series, just letting you know
1 replies
25redshark
2 hours
Same
Ajsrippedpantsfromtlc2016
6 hours
I hope you guys rewatch at least the extended editions of at least this one considering it has some huge things that are just missing from the theatrical release
ernestova891
7 hours
first comment! this is one of my favorite movies ever!
1 replies
Msr9272tce
7 hours
up there with revenge of the sith for me, probably top 5 or 10
definitely do extended when you can work it in.
ya i would be down for the extended editions and the hobbit movies
i would be very interest in his "better solution" for the Oliphant charge......please do a video on his expertise on medieval cavalry warfare
So funny enough, the book that Frodo was writing in at the end is supposed to have been the original manuscript that Tolkien merely translated. Within his own writing, Tolkien placed himself as a sort of linguistic historian who was building out this "missing historical myth" of England. So the Lord of the Rings is more of an autobiography by Frodo, with the accounts of the other perspectives from the other members of the Fellowship.
I would totally rewatch the series but you should do the extended editions
With the "nothing to combat dragons" technically those aren't dragons but i guess it still stands, but dragons are basically extinct at the time of LOTR, there might be one or two hanging around but they would not be living where people are, so most nations would not be expecting an attack by dragons or dragonlike beings
Glad you guys enjoyed the Lord of the Rings, hope you guys do watch the extended editions, even if you don’t record them, you should watch them for your own enjoyment. As for the Hibbit movies, I personally enjoyed them, they weren’t as good as the Lord of the Rings, but I find the extended editions are much better than the theatrical versions. So my option is you watch them instead of the theatrical, if you guys decide to watch the hobbit. They aren’t as bad as people make them out to be.
Konrad Kyeser was a famous German siege engineer who wrote a book about siege warfare
I think the books go into more detail, but Faramir's father was using a Palantir and it corrupted his mind just enough to lose hope and faith, and to go psycho.
I have a special request... You should look up Elijah Wood (Frodo) and Sean Astin (Samwise) play baldurs gate 3 with the head of larian studio, its such a funny marketed ad video.
The Hobbit movies would be fine if they hadn't insisted on trying to recreate some of the scenes that make LOTR so memorable, ie: Arwen's entrance > Evangeline showing up to heal the dwarf. For whatever reason the studio wouldn't leave Jackson alone and let The Hobbit just be what it is. HOWEVER, they do add in quite a bit of cannon lore that is happening in the book but wasn't written in the book. One thing Tolkien wished was that he had made The Hobbit darker like his later books. All that said I think they are worth watching and very entertaining. If for no other reason than you get 'Jackson lore' behind why Legolas apparently never runs out of arrows and his glorious campaign of 'Don't touch my stuff!' 🤣
it's hillarious they thought that the 4 kids at Sam's wedding were his and Rosie's. Like how fast do they think Hobbits grow.
I'm gonna say it- no dinosaurs could fly. Pterosaurs could, but they were a distinct group from dinosaurs.
Check out the Hobbit movies too!
https://x.com/DiscussingFilm/status/1864371947389210686 thought this might interest you guys
The land the elves are going Is also where the gods live and there are no elves besides aowyn and legolas left in middleearth the rest left and even then legolas only leave when gimli is at the end of his life and legolas also brings him to the undying lands.
I will happily watch the extended editions with you guys. I can not believe how many scenes were cut out of the theatrical version! Like this edition is great, the story is fantastic and I still cry either way. Loved the reactions. I would be down for The Hobbit trilogy too. I still very much enjoyed The Hobbit movies a lot. It gave me more to experience in this world and so much more backstory. Cannon-ness can be debated later. I think you all would love watching them too, they are fun.
So I only recently found you guys on Youtube, and after watching a few of the videos on there, I knew I had to join the Patreon to get access to the whole videos. I feel like watching these is like watching a movie with my buddies, but one where I can sit by and play a video game at the same time and not get badgered about it. Seriously, you guys are great, and I appreciate this kind of content.
10,000 soldiers of Gondor
6,000 Riders of Rohan
about 4000 reinforcements + ghosts
200,000 orcs and friends
Elf smiths are just really well good and don't need to start over by melting the sword down all the way
High key down for a rewatch with the extended editions
Yes please to watching the extended editions!
It was about 200.000 orcs against 10.000 gondorian soldiers and 6.000 riders of Rohan.
I would gladly watch you rewatch the whole series for the Extended Editions. IMO Fellowship of the Ring and Return of the King extended are the definitive editions of these movies.
Same
I second this
I'm pretty sure the Orlando Bloom video is when they were filming The Hobbit, goofing around between takes.
yes rewatch the exrtended woooo
We will absolutely rewatch yall rewatch the trilogy extended editions!
Hell yes, a rewatch with the extended editions?! You sonofabitch, I'm in.
Yes react to the extendeds!
Return of the King is a stunning conclusion to the trilogy, Recommend watching the extended editions at some point adds much more depth to the story. hope you guys react to the hobbit
1000 times yessss please make recording of your extended editions rewatch
This
Such a shame, you guys didn’t watch the extended edition, but I’m glad you guys enjoyed it. I hope you watch them anyway.
i wanna watch you re-watch the whole series, just letting you know
Same
I hope you guys rewatch at least the extended editions of at least this one considering it has some huge things that are just missing from the theatrical release
first comment! this is one of my favorite movies ever!
up there with revenge of the sith for me, probably top 5 or 10