You Shall Not Pass!

To view this content, you must be a member of Sorta Stupid Patreon at $15 or more

Already a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to access this content.

Billy - Gold

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King Reaction

The Lord of The Rings |

150 Comments

  1. Commenters avatar
    Skippy
    17 days

    Might be late to the party but I would absolutely watch you guys react to pretty much everything Lord of Rings! Extended, Hobbit, the old cartoons, etc. Everything but Rings of Power lol.

  2. Commenters avatar
    Eric
    30 days

    in the book, Gimli actually went to the undying lands as well. he left along with Legolas, being given the honor of joining the final journey

  3. Commenters avatar
    Sean
    2 months

    I dont know any Tolkien fan that has a problem with eaowyn killing the witch King. It's such a beautifully set up homage to the " no man born of woman" loophole from Macbeth.

    Expand 1 reply
    1. fatalbeast22
      1 month

      only issue i have is the movie doesnt properly explain that the reason shes able to kill him, is because of the special blade he was stabbed with 5 seconds earlier lol

  4. sunnstr1der
    2 months

    Please watch the extended editions! 

  5. Commenters avatar
    Amaranth
    3 months

    Yessssss, please watch the extended editions

  6. Commenters avatar
    Callum
    5 months

    I would absolutely watch you guys react to the entire series again, and I really really Really hope you do The Hobbit movies too!!

  7. Commenters avatar
    Swordfish
    5 months

    I'd say watch the cartoon Hobbit movie first, maybe even the Lord of Rings cartoon as well for shirts and giggles, and then go into the movies. The movies are fine enough, but knowing how the cartoon Hobbit is better before hand would give you an idea on why people hate on the Hobbit Trilogy.

  8. Commenters avatar
    Ben
    5 months

    I would 100% want you guys to watch the extended versions, they make the movies so much better. Also while they are not as good as Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit movies are still good and you should definitely watch them. The second film has my favourite villain in any of the Hobbit or LOTR films. 

  9. Commenters avatar
    nick.draper
    5 months

    So, are you going to be playing the Shadow of Mordor/War games on the channel?

  10. Commenters avatar
    nick.draper
    5 months

    Huh, never noticed the drastic difference between extended and theater editions before. You guys didn't even see what happened to Saruman.

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      Annie519
      3 months

      I know! It still bothers me that they took it out. It feels so incomplete, it honestly leaves so many holes in the story. Saying that Saruman is just took weak now to do any harm is such a lame excuse to wright him out, they don't even explain what happened to Grima and this version Pippin just randomly finds the orb too. You can tell things were cut. And I know Christopher Lee was also very upset they removed it. This movie with the extended version is already over 4 hours long, 5 or so more minutes wouldn't have mattered, especially for such an important scene. 

  11. Commenters avatar
    Robin
    6 months

    Ooh yeah, there is a funny clip where Elijah and Sean are playing co-op Baldur's Gate and Elijah doesn't want to get rid of an evil item, so Sean just pushes Elijah's character in the lava. xD

  12. Commenters avatar
    Robin
    6 months

    There is a new animated Lord of the Rings movie called the war of the Roirrim. And I still need you guys to watch the biopic Tolkien.

  13. Commenters avatar
    Garrett
    6 months

    The first Hobbit movie is good. The 2nd is okay & ths 3rd is not great. But worth watching for sure!.. & seriously the extended editions are incredible. 4k & all is nutz!! Return of the King & Two Towers especially are better movies extended.

  14. Commenters avatar
    Garrett
    6 months

    Eowyn was always loved by LOTR fans. Her "I am no man" wasn't considered cringe. Miranda Otto the actor even talks about this in an interview

  15. Commenters avatar
    Garrett
    6 months

    PLEASE watch the extended editions. They are even better & you guys have had an amazing reaction to the theatrical. Second viewing is even better

  16. Commenters avatar
    Vesper
    6 months

    Good news, though: Sam was eventually permitted to go to the Undying Lands to live out the rest of his days with Frodo.

  17. Commenters avatar
    Vesper
    6 months

    Sam was definitely the hero of the story, the Ring tempted him exactly once and it promised to make him the best gardener in all the shire, and he said "no I'm fine thanks"

  18. zach_the_artist
    6 months

    I'd love to see the extended versions~

  19. Commenters avatar
    Reran
    6 months

    rewatch the whhole series extended

  20. Commenters avatar
    Oscar
    6 months

    Lol at the end during the Orlando Bloom meme video when Sean noticed they were accidentally spoiling future things.

  21. Commenters avatar
    allen
    6 months

    So when is the extended edition coming?

  22. geekygiraffe
    6 months

    I would absolutely love to see you react to the extended versions, or at the very least a few of the scenes from extended! 

  23. Commenters avatar
    Rey
    6 months

    Definitely watched the hobbit,and have Bree watch the extended version with you

  24. Commenters avatar
    Benjamin
    6 months

    I would 100% watch a re-watch reaction series to the extended editions, and also reactions to the extensive behind the scenes content 

  25. Commenters avatar
    Nattis_O
    6 months

    I also would recomend to watch behind the scenes if you have the extended editions. It is really fascinating how they progressed in making these movies. And the way they did it if fairly unique. I sometimes just put them on to have in the background and listen to it. The process is insane, with costumes, props, drawing board, script, actors, stunt people, their struggles and blupers. I would love to see someone react to them. They are long and you might not want to react to them all but they are really interesting to see behind the scenes. And if you ever are going to watch the behind the scenes this trilogy is the one to do it!

  26. Commenters avatar
    Nattis_O
    6 months

    It has been sooo long sense I have seen the original movies and not the extended cut. It feels so weird. You expect certain scenes and they are just not there. XD

  27. Commenters avatar
    Nerveroxis
    6 months

    Boom really likes to make assumptions about things and say them like he knows info, like just say "I'm not sure".

  28. Commenters avatar
    CapnC
    6 months

    Yes please the extended editions & the animated movies from the 80's

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      CapnC
      6 months

      Also may want to check out 'A simpl Walk' where people from Roosterteeth walk the distance from the Shire to Mordor in New Zeland

  29. Commenters avatar
    Patrick
    6 months

    I don't remember if this was in the book, but the fact that there were 3 eagles that came to rescue Sam and Frodo from Mount Doom makes me think that Gandalf had a little bit of hope that Smeagol would still be alive at the end.

  30. left_testicle
    6 months

    god this trilogy is so good I'd even watch a rewatch of the entire thing

  31. Commenters avatar
    Patrick
    6 months

    the palantir bit can be summed up as follows: "Bad news, Sauron now knows everything Pippin knows. Good news, Pippin doesn't know shit."

  32. Commenters avatar
    Wanbli
    6 months

    Yall just talked all the way through Rohirrim charge. About nothing even related to movie.  There is no greater battle charge in cinema and y’all just talked all through Theoden speech not even paying attention. Disappointing to say the least.

  33. Commenters avatar
    Wanbli
    6 months

    It is absolutely criminal to not watch Extended. Makes zero sense to watch theatrical. So much missed content.

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      Alice
      6 months

      agreed! I've only ever watched the extended edition and I had no idea that the theatrical completely skips Sarumon's death!

  34. sunnstr1der
    6 months

    You should absolutely watch the extended editions. The extended editions are considered to be in the S tier above the theatrical release. 

  35. Commenters avatar
    julian
    6 months

    You guys should watch the rankin bass hobbit movie it looks silly but it’s a way better adaptation of the hobbit than the three movies 

  36. Commenters avatar
    KeterLordFR
    6 months

    Fun fact : the kid that Sam picks up at the end is Sean Astin's daughter. A little detail that I always love.

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      RaynnMJ
      6 months

      and the Baby his wife is holding is her actual daughter.

  37. Commenters avatar
    beetle
    6 months

    Definitely watch rings of power 

  38. Commenters avatar
    Nerdy
    6 months

    Yes! Definitely watch the extended editions!

  39. Commenters avatar
    Ruukasu97
    6 months

    SamVP

  40. Commenters avatar
    SGM
    6 months

    Fun fact: Most of the Rohirrim were women with beards. They were asking for owners of horses to fill in to be extras. Most of those who showed were women with their own horses. So yeah most were wearing helmets all the time and the fake beard.

  41. Commenters avatar
    Pangurban
    6 months

    Please watch the extended edition. We will watch all of it!

  42. Commenters avatar
    Pangurban
    6 months

    I loved the reaction to the movie and the cartoon!  Fantastic!

  43. Commenters avatar
    Joshua
    6 months

    Please, watch them again as extended edition.

  44. Commenters avatar
    mikehawk
    6 months

    of course we want y'all to watch them again

  45. Commenters avatar
    Sly
    6 months

    The Hobbit movies aren’t nearly as good but they’re fun!! If you go in prepared understanding it’s not the same caliber, they’re just fine. The Rings of Power is NOT worth your time. Many people who are die hard fans couldn’t get through the second season- even most reactors just said ‘hey we can’t finish the series, sorry guys’..

  46. Commenters avatar
    Rowan
    6 months

    100% watch the Hobbit movies, but if you want a nearly accurate version, there is a 4 hour edited version. The M4 fan edit was made with the book in hand. That being said, I'm personally quite fond of the additions just for fun.  Heres the link to the fan edit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ZKmXqXxtVc

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      Connor
      6 months

      I actually think the fan edit is worse than the trilogy.

      If the trilogy is bloated, the fan edit is desiccated. Even with all the fluff and fan service in the trilogy cut out there's still 2 movies worth of film, cutting down to 1 movie was an insane choice.

  47. Commenters avatar
    Sean
    6 months

    To answer your question about army sizes at the battle of pelenor fields ... its ticky. 

    The only cannon sources are in the novel but in the novel the ghost army does not come to Minas Tirith. It only helps deal with the corsair ships. Aragorn then rallies the released southern gondor defense armies which is who he brings to release gondor on the black ships.

    So book army sizes are thus:

    Gondor defense army: 3000

    Rohirrim Cavalry: 6000

    Aragorn's southern gondor relief army: about 5000 max

    Orcs/ eastern Evil men: 10s of thousands ( like atleast 20,000 min)

    Trolls, Eliphants, etc: close to 1000

    Plus the Nazgul.

  48. Commenters avatar
    Sean
    6 months

    I'm in the same boat with Mikala, I havent watched the theatrical versions since they were in theaters. I'd forgotten how much worse the writing is in alot of scenes with the extended material cut. Esspecially the opening were ( without the extended material) they seem to ride to isengard for absolutely no reason. Like why exactly did Gandalf, theodin, gimli and the rest go to isengard on this version exactly?

    I know from a move the plot forward perspective they need to find pippin and merry and the pilantiri ( probably spelled that wrong) 

    But the characters had no way to KNOW marry and pippin where at isengard till they got there.

    The extended cut gives a valid reason for why they all went to isengard following helms deep AND if you watched the extended Two towers you understand while the forest suddenly extends all the way up to isengard walls when in the last shot we see in theatrical it's been cut back for miles from isengard

  49. Commenters avatar
    Mikala
    6 months

    You NEED to watch the extended editions. I think you should also record them. There are so many scenes that I would love to see your reactions to. I haven't watched the theatrical versions since I was a kid and watching along with you guys, there were definitely some scenes that I feel like are SO good and should have been included.

  50. Commenters avatar
    Tone
    6 months

    PLEASE record reactions to the Extended Editions when you watch them!

  51. Commenters avatar
    James
    6 months

    Interesting information for your rewatch through the extended versions - Sam was not the first person that willingly gave up the ring when he gives it back after Shelob paralyzed Frodo.  It was actually Bilbo in Fellowship of the Ring back at his home when Gandalf told him to leave it and he willingly dropped it on the ground, which is why that particular scene was shot with so much intensity with the music, but without knowing why it's significant it seems out of place at first.

  52. Commenters avatar
    Lucy
    6 months

    Yes!! Re-watch with the extended and then the Hobbit. But do the Hobbit extended as well 

  53. Commenters avatar
    Eli
    6 months

    Really looking forward to seeing how this journey continues with the extended editions, the hobbit, ROP, and even the new animated film. Exciting times for LOTR fans!

  54. Commenters avatar
    ManiacKuzco
    6 months

    Please for the love of all that is holy watch the extended versions, I will gladly rewatch them with you. God LOTR is soooo good and I love that Ruff is like I WANT MOOOAARR and I love that for him. 

  55. Commenters avatar
    Cloud
    6 months

    I always assumed the Land of the Undying was actually just a place where they all rest in piece, not a place to continue living. Especially after Gandalf explained there is more after death? So, considering elves don't actually die of age, but if they grow tired of living, they sail to that island to actually let themselves pass on in a respectable place, an elf graveyard, if you will. BUT, that's just how I understood it.

  56. mayasha_chan
    6 months

    Such a fantastic film and film series! Absolutely would love to see you guys react to the extended versions. Funnily enough, when my Dad introduced me to the series he only ever showed me the extended editions but never called them that, so I always thought those were the only version of the films.

  57. davordirewulf
    6 months

    A cool detail you can see in this movie is how bruised Frodo’s neck is where the chain holding the ring is. It quite literally weighing on him.

  58. Commenters avatar
    Trever
    6 months

    I never realized it before but a gambling Legolas share a horse when they're going to the Mountain with Aragorn nice to touch the show the development of their friendships and Trust since they both started out pretty much racist toward each other

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      Trever
      6 months

      * Gimli and Legolas

  59. Commenters avatar
    NickLay
    6 months

    I't would be nice if you watched the extended editions becuase i don't know where to watch them and google is convinced they are on prime and max

  60. hurryupmode
    6 months

    Bruh I've watched the extended edition trilogy like 4 times this year. Hell yeah I'll watch ya'll do an extended edition rewatch

  61. Commenters avatar
    Legend_of_Bharhash
    6 months

    I have loved the Lord of The Rings movies since they came out so I'm very glad to see you all enjoy them so much. In my opinion, it is the only book made movies where the movies are better than the books. I'm sure I'm in the minority of those that believe this but the books were hard to read and I just feel the movies captured the writing of Tolkien and presented them much better than my imagination ever could. I would be down to watch you all react to the extended versions!

  62. Commenters avatar
    MMifzz
    6 months

    The lore is far more deeper and Lord of The Rings only covers the top peak of the iceberg. One could say the first dark lord is the main character which the entire lore/legendarium revolves around...as he is the common denominator through out it. 

  63. nostradamus0791
    6 months

    If you care about the lore, Rings of Power is not the way to go. They only had access to the appendix of a book and all the Tolkien scholars left the making of the show because of the lore changes they kept making 

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      John
      6 months

      I thought the primary reasoning for that was the Tolkien estate wouldn't allow them to use The Silmarillion so they just picked what they could legally use.

      Expand 1 reply
      1. nostradamus0791
        6 months

        Right, all they had legal access to was the appendix lol. They never should’ve tried to make the show with what they had access to. They should’ve just made their own show unattached to Tolkien 

  64. dealerrat
    6 months

    I actually lovee The Hobbit movies too

  65. jemx27
    6 months

    If you want more Elijah, he voices a yeti named Saxaphone in summer camp island! 

  66. dealerrat
    6 months

    the way I was waiting for that "Fool of a Took" for 20 minutes. Gandalf also said it in the first movie when Pippin knocked over all the armour and chains down the well in the dwarf place

  67. Commenters avatar
    Benjamin
    6 months

    they sail to Valinot at the end. its the land of the gods and the original home of the elves. Death does not exist there, so they will never die while being there. It also it not physically on earth. Its outside, so normally you cannot get there, but the gods granted the elves and certain individuals like Frodo, Bilbo and even Gimli to come

    Expand 2 replies
    1. Commenters avatar
      John
      6 months

      Mortals are not granted eternal life in Valinor. They simply get to enjoy the remainder of their lives in comfort and without pain. Tolkien mentions the Valar can't make fundamental changes to mortals. Only Eru (essentially the creator of all) can grant immortality. So technically it's possible for Frodo, Bilbo, and Gimli to be granted eternal life, but we don't know for sure.

      What's wild is there was some text where Tolkien alluded to mortal lives actually being shortened in Valinor. Though no idea if that's canon or not.

    2. Commenters avatar
      Benjamin
      6 months

      *Valinor

  68. Whispie
    6 months

    I think it's good to watch the theatrical versions first. I love the extended versions. I think those are great if you want a longer stay in Middle Earth, to learn more, and have a longer adventure. However, the theatrical versions are the essential experience. Peter Jackson himself says the theatrical versions are the definitive versions. I do think there are many extended version bits you would love. Maybe give it a year or two, then give them a watch. Hobbit movies first though!

  69. Commenters avatar
    Benjamin
    6 months

    Did you guys seriously talk over the epic Brave Heart moment from Theoden? Dudes, really???

  70. nostradamus0791
    6 months

    So fun fact; they needed so many extras for the battle of the black gate, that they called in the New Zealand army Reserves. And they all got really into it and took it seriously 😂

  71. Commenters avatar
    Pip
    6 months

    Another good Lord of the Rings game that might be under the radar is Return to Moria.

  72. Commenters avatar
    Dinamo89
    6 months

    Extended scene reaction! Yes!!!

  73. Commenters avatar
    JM
    6 months

    Ride of the Rohirrim is one of my favorite scenes in basically any movie, ever. I can't describe what it was like to see on the big screen when it released. In-universe, there are six thousand riders with Theoden. In reality, it was several hundred extras charging across a large field. They put out an open casting call for anyone with a horse who knew how to ride, and the majority of people who showed up were women, so that scene involves a whole lot of female riders wearing beards and face obscuring helmets. 

    I would watch the shit out of you guys watching the extended editions. The LotR trilogy is a masterpiece, the extended editions are masterpiece+. The thing about them though is that while there are definitely entire scenes that weren't in the theatrical cuts, there are also a *lot* of scenes that were in the theatrical release but were edited down for time (or, sometimes, references to scenes that were cut), that have been restored. So it's possible to Youtube the new ones, but the changes aren't as clean as simply adding new scenes. If you had to watch only one of the extended edition movies, though, I'd definitely point at Return of the King. That movie is so dense with material that some genuinely important stuff got left out, such as what happened to Saruman, or why, after Gandalf says Sauron won't take the bait of them marching on the Black Gates, he ends up doing so anyway. 

    There's hours and hours of behind the scenes stuff that came with the original release of the extended editions. Some of it probably wouldn't make good reaction material even if it's awesome because it gets into a lot of the technical details of sets, special effects, etc, but I do recommend the three (I think there are three?) segments on Tolkien, and Fellowship of the Cast. There are segments on how they adapted each book, but it's been a long time since I saw them so I don't remember enough to know if they'd be a good reaction watch. I know there's a segment about Andy Serkis throwing himself around all over doing the motion capture, and how they turned that performance into the Gollum that's onscreen.

    I love the Hobbit book, but the movies are an example of Hollywood doing what  Hollywood does. They wanted another Lord of the Rings, and the Hobbit is, on top of being a single novel that's not remotely as dense as LotR, a book that was aimed to include a younger audience. There's a lot more whimsy in the Hobbit than LotR, so the movies have some serious tone problems on top of being stretched beyond reason. Production and filming were also hell. It was originally going to be directed by Guillermo del Toro (I'm so sad we didn't get to see his version), before he left the project over, ahem, creative differences, and Peter Jackson was effectively hauled back in without much time at all to write let alone direct. The actors do their damnedest and the movies are kind of amazingly better than you'd expect given what was going on behind the scenes, but the quality downgrade from 'absolute masterpiece' is very noticeable. I'd wait a little bit to watch them, because I think you'd enjoy them more if there was some breather space between them and this.

  74. Commenters avatar
    Shalah
    6 months

    I would absolutely 100% watch y'all watch the Extended Editions. Also, I have SUCH a hard time watching this movie because Sam's crying gets me every time. But I stuck it out to watch with y'all and I'd do it again!

  75. Commenters avatar
    Captain
    6 months

    Only morons bitched about Eowyns line when she took down the Witch-King. They failed to realize its verbatim what she said and did in the books from fucking 1955. Its what us nerds wanted. 

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      JM
      6 months

      I'm sure there were people in 1955 livid about Eowyn's inclusion in the novels, but happily we did not have the internet so they either had to fume in obscurity or write angry letters about it.

  76. Commenters avatar
    John
    6 months

    There's also a funny theory that Frodo doesn't actually know Legolas' name. He doesn't explicitly ever state Legolas' name ever in the films. In the reunion scene when Legolas enters the room, Frodo doesn't say his name like the others while also having an odd look on his face. Technically, the pages Frodo writes at the end of the film does mention Legolas, but it could mean he just asked Sam for the name much later lol.

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      Trever
      6 months

      And here I am scanning comments because I brain farted his name 😶‍🌫️🤣😶‍🌫️

  77. Commenters avatar
    John
    6 months

    My understanding with Frodo and Bilbo traveling to the Undying Lands with Gandalf and the elves was to give them peace and comfort for the rest of their mortal lives. As Ring Bearers, their lives were tormented for some time. It's especially evident with Frodo and his stab wound from Weathertop. Think of it as a means to completely ease any pain and PTSD.

    In the books, there were a few more who eventually travel to the Undying Lands. Sam also goes to the Undying Lands after his wife Rosie passes. He entrusts the Red Book to his daughter and went to the Grey Havens because he too was technically a Ring-bearer - albeit for a short time. Both he and Frodo reunite there. 120 years after the War of the Ring, Legolas also took Gimli as an honored guest to the Undying Lands out of the latter's desire to see the beauty of Galadriel again. He became the first Dwarf to visit the Undying Lands.

  78. Commenters avatar
    Kollie123
    6 months

    One thing I say in regards to the extended editions is I think return of the king has one of the worse ones in terms of a first watch.

    The theatrical cut doesn’t show Aragorn again from the moment he asks the ghosts to help and they show up to help, you don’t even get a response on if the ghosts are going to help. It creates natural tension suspense.

    Sure some watchers can probably guess or assume the ghosts will come to save the day, but in terms of objective story telling knowing the ghosts are already going to help and are on their way undersells the entire battle.

    When you know for 100% fact the ghosts are coming the main battle just feels like you’re waiting for them to come save the day, while in the theatrical cut you don’t fully know if they are coming, or if the men might pull something else off 

    Like I said it’s not a deep or complex moment, but I think from an objective perspective the story flows better when viewer isn’t shown the ghosts agree to help and are on their way 

  79. Commenters avatar
    Loki
    6 months

    Not as a reaction but you guys should check out the behind the scenes for these movies, there both interesting and hilarious, especially the parts about Andy Serkis becoming Gollum. He originally was only going to be the voice, but his performance while reading convinced perter that he needed to mocap as well

  80. Commenters avatar
    strawhat441s
    6 months

    Definitely need to watch the Hobbit trilogy

  81. grigsy87
    6 months

    I havn’t seen the theatrical versions since the theater. The extended versions feel like a completely different movie (better). 

  82. Commenters avatar
    sithlord661977
    6 months

    You guys should also watch all the old animated Lord of the Rings and Hobbit movies

  83. Commenters avatar
    sithlord661977
    6 months

    I'm so happy how much Ruff loved these movies. Also I would love to see you guys watch the Extended Editions, there is so much extra stuff which expands and add upon things. I can't wait for you guys to watch the Hobbit movies aswell. Rings of Power is up to you guys, I'd recommend atleast checking it out. You guys should watch the War of the Rohirrim animated movie coming out soon

  84. Commenters avatar
    Pascall
    6 months

    This was so good! If you like Peter Jackson's stuff I would love to see y'all watch the Peter Jackson King Kong. Weird movie but lots of awesome huge set pieces and great CGI! 

  85. Commenters avatar
    Melissa
    6 months

    Please Watch the Hobbit Trilogy next!! It's not the original trilogy but it has its own charm and honestly a fun time.

  86. Commenters avatar
    Barbara
    6 months

    random request, but when's the last time you guys saw the original Jurassic Park? that'd be super cool to see a reaction of

  87. Commenters avatar
    Alex
    6 months

    Hobbit yes, Rings of Power no.

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      Captain
      6 months

      Agreed. ones just a bloated project that still has the heart of tolkien in it. RoP is just awful sludge that shits on the world of tolkien

      Expand 1 reply
      1. Commenters avatar
        Kollie123
        6 months

        Oh please the hobbit movies are filled with nonsense, I can’t take any dorks seriously who are willing to give those movies a pass while whining about rings of power 

  88. Commenters avatar
    Barbara
    6 months

    I would love to watch the extended version with Y'all, never seen it, always wanted to

  89. Commenters avatar
    Crimson
    6 months

    You guys should definitely check out some nerd of the rings videos if you want a deeper dive into the lore.

  90. Commenters avatar
    JRax
    6 months

    As great as these movies are the major thing that annoyed me with this movie series is Frodo himself quite possibly one of the most incompetent main character characters of all time

    Expand 2 replies
    1. Commenters avatar
      Bluhawke
      6 months

      Tell me you didn't understand one of the major themes of the story without telling me you didn't understand one of the major themes of the story 

    2. Commenters avatar
      Loki
      6 months

      To be fair, the guy is pretty preoccupied carrying the all corrupting item on his neck the whole time, the same item that outright turns most people on sight.

  91. Commenters avatar
    Msr9272tce
    6 months

    definitely do extended when you can work it in. 

  92. Commenters avatar
    Ken
    6 months

    ya i would be down for the extended editions and the hobbit movies

  93. Commenters avatar
    Vegvisir92
    6 months

    i would be very interest in his "better solution" for the Oliphant charge......please do a video on his expertise on medieval cavalry warfare

  94. adacor
    6 months

    So funny enough, the book that Frodo was writing in at the end is supposed to have been the original manuscript that Tolkien merely translated. Within his own writing, Tolkien placed himself as a sort of linguistic historian who was building out this "missing historical myth" of England. So the Lord of the Rings is more of an autobiography by Frodo, with the accounts of the other perspectives from the other members of the Fellowship.

  95. Commenters avatar
    awesomestudios17
    6 months

    I would totally rewatch the series but you should do the extended editions 

  96. Commenters avatar
    Vegvisir92
    6 months

    With the "nothing to combat dragons" technically those aren't dragons but i guess it still stands, but dragons are basically extinct at the time of LOTR, there might be one or two hanging around but they would not be living where people are, so most nations would not be expecting an attack by dragons or dragonlike beings

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      MMifzz
      6 months

      Those one or two possible dragons probably are just the sea serpents

  97. Commenters avatar
    Jett
    6 months

    Glad you guys enjoyed the Lord of the Rings, hope you guys do watch the extended editions, even if you don’t record them, you should watch them for your own enjoyment. As for the Hibbit movies, I personally enjoyed them, they weren’t as good as the Lord of the Rings, but I find the extended editions are much better than the theatrical versions. So my option is you watch them instead of the theatrical, if you guys decide to watch the hobbit. They aren’t as bad as people make them out to be.

  98. Commenters avatar
    Vegvisir92
    6 months

    Konrad Kyeser was a famous German siege engineer who wrote a book about siege warfare

  99. lightning132ttv
    6 months

    I think the books go into more detail, but Faramir's father was using a Palantir and it corrupted his mind just enough to lose hope and faith, and to go psycho.

  100. Commenters avatar
    Jam
    6 months

    I have a special request... You should look up Elijah Wood (Frodo) and Sean Astin (Samwise) play baldurs gate 3 with the head of larian studio, its such a funny marketed ad video.

  101. Commenters avatar
    LaLa
    6 months

    The Hobbit movies would be fine if they hadn't insisted on trying to recreate some of the scenes that make LOTR so memorable,  ie: Arwen's entrance > Evangeline showing up to heal the dwarf. For whatever reason the studio wouldn't leave Jackson alone and let The Hobbit just be what it is. HOWEVER, they do add in quite a bit of cannon lore that is happening in the book but wasn't written in the book. One thing Tolkien wished was that he had made The Hobbit darker like his later books. All that said I think they are worth watching and very entertaining. If for no other reason than you get 'Jackson lore' behind why Legolas apparently never runs out of arrows and his glorious campaign of 'Don't touch my stuff!' 🤣

  102. Commenters avatar
    Jean
    6 months

    4,000 Gondorians

    6,000 Rohirrim

    50,000 undead soldiers

    200,000 Orcs

    2,000 Corsairs

    20 Mûmakil

    2,000 Haradrim

    4 Ringwraiths

    20+ Trolls

    Was the amount in the films for the armies

  103. kekkers
    6 months

    it's hillarious they thought that the 4 kids at Sam's wedding were his and Rosie's.  Like how fast do they think Hobbits grow. 

  104. Commenters avatar
    Adam
    6 months

    I'm gonna say it- no dinosaurs could fly. Pterosaurs could, but they were a distinct group from dinosaurs.

  105. Commenters avatar
    25redshark
    6 months

    Check out the Hobbit movies too!

  106. Commenters avatar
    Kayla
    6 months

    https://x.com/DiscussingFilm/status/1864371947389210686 thought this might interest you guys

  107. Commenters avatar
    Y0GE
    6 months

    The land the elves are going Is also where the gods live and there are no elves besides aowyn and legolas left in middleearth the rest left and even then legolas only leave when gimli is at the end of his life and legolas also brings him to the undying lands.

  108. Commenters avatar
    Wonderxfull
    6 months

    I will happily watch the extended editions with you guys. I can not believe how many scenes were cut out of the theatrical version!  Like this edition is great, the story is fantastic and I still cry either way. Loved the reactions. I would be down for The Hobbit trilogy too. I still very much enjoyed The Hobbit movies a lot. It gave me more to experience in this world and so much more backstory. Cannon-ness can be debated later. I think you all would love watching them too, they are fun.

  109. Commenters avatar
    Kelph1
    6 months

    So I only recently found you guys on Youtube, and after watching a few of the videos on there, I knew I had to join the Patreon to get access to the whole videos.  I feel like watching these is like watching a movie with my buddies, but one where I can sit by and play a video game at the same time and not get badgered about it.  Seriously, you guys are great, and I appreciate this kind of content.

  110. Commenters avatar
    jachinsnelson
    6 months

    10,000 soldiers of Gondor

    6,000 Riders of Rohan

    about 4000 reinforcements + ghosts

    200,000 orcs and friends 

  111. Commenters avatar
    DesertDrifter
    6 months

    Elf smiths are just really well good and don't need to start over by melting the sword down all the way

  112. ammy95.
    6 months

    High key down for a rewatch with the extended editions

  113. Commenters avatar
    Jonathan
    6 months

    Yes please to watching the extended editions!

  114. Commenters avatar
    Cat
    6 months

    It was about 200.000 orcs against 10.000 gondorian soldiers and 6.000 riders of Rohan.

  115. Commenters avatar
    MrAlexSan
    6 months

    I would gladly watch you rewatch the whole series for the Extended Editions. IMO Fellowship of the Ring and Return of the King extended are the definitive editions of these movies.

    Expand 2 replies
    1. Commenters avatar
      25redshark
      6 months

      Same

    2. lightning132ttv
      6 months

      I second this

  116. Commenters avatar
    Chainshada
    6 months

    I'm pretty sure the Orlando Bloom video is when they were filming The Hobbit, goofing around between takes.

  117. Commenters avatar
    Ramba_Ya
    6 months

    yes rewatch the exrtended woooo

  118. Commenters avatar
    Ajsrippedpantsfromtlc2016
    6 months

    We will absolutely rewatch yall rewatch the trilogy extended editions!

  119. Commenters avatar
    Makix217
    6 months

    Hell yes, a rewatch with the extended editions?! You sonofabitch, I'm in. 

  120. Commenters avatar
    25redshark
    6 months

    Yes react to the extendeds!

  121. Commenters avatar
    Vexxar
    6 months

    Return of the King is a stunning conclusion to the trilogy, Recommend watching the extended editions at some point adds much more depth to the story. hope you guys react to the hobbit

  122. Commenters avatar
    Queer Lynx
    6 months

    1000 times yessss please make recording of your extended editions rewatch 

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      25redshark
      6 months

      This

  123. Commenters avatar
    Andrew
    6 months

    Such a shame, you guys didn’t watch the extended edition, but I’m glad you guys enjoyed it. I hope you watch them anyway.

  124. cdmellow
    6 months

    i wanna watch you re-watch the whole series, just letting you know

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      25redshark
      6 months

      Same

  125. Commenters avatar
    Ajsrippedpantsfromtlc2016
    6 months

    I hope you guys rewatch at least the extended editions of at least this one considering it has some huge things that are just missing from the theatrical release

  126. Commenters avatar
    ernestova891
    6 months

    first comment! this is one of my favorite movies ever!

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      Msr9272tce
      6 months

      up there with revenge of the sith for me, probably top 5 or 10

Related

Recommended

Patreon Join Our Patreon