You Shall Not Pass!

To view this content, you must be a member of Sorta Stupid Patreon at $25 or more

Already a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to access this content.

Billy - Diamond

Doctor Who S4 Episode 1 Reaction

Doctor Who |

29 Comments

  1. eaglemyles
    9 days

    Rose held a high place for me as she was the original and it was the relationship with the Doctor that just made you rate her more. Honestly I didn't like her with Eccleston but I did with Tennant. It was Tennants Doctors emotion that made you like her more imo

    I can remember not really liking Martha too much and tbh I think it was a combination of her being the first 'change' of companion and also I felt she always had this over the top emotion and the fact she just wanted the doctor all the time. If they had dropped that aspect maybe id like her more but she was more efficient for sure.

    Donna will always be number 1, Captain Jack is my all time favourite 'Third', and then a couple of companions in later seasons next followed by Rose, Martha and then a couple others from later seasons last

    Side note - Wilfred Mott is the greatest non companion character ever

  2. Commenters avatar
    nbcardall
    18 days

    Good ole Wilfred Mott, an all time Who character.

  3. Commenters avatar
    Chloe
    28 days

    hoping to get more of these soon!

  4. Commenters avatar
    norton.shannon.l2
    1 month

    Keep the episodes coming! I have had so much fun rewatching the series with you guys!

  5. ayyitsalii
    1 month

    Honestly, watching Doctor Who as a kid, I didn't have as strong of an opinion about Rose until I grew up and rewatched it and realised how much I Did actually hate her lmao.

  6. Commenters avatar
    Neela
    1 month

    As someone who grew up watching from the start of David Tennant era of Dr Who, I hated Rose with a passion. The only good thing about her is that she made every other companion seem so much better 

    Expand 1 reply
    1. eaglemyles
      9 days

      Funny as I never saw that. I didn't like her too much in season 1 but in season 2 I think it was Tennants emotion that made me like her more

      Donna and then (some other characters I can't name but second of Smiths and first of Smith's come second and third for me)

  7. Commenters avatar
    Red
    1 month

    I hope u watch the 11th hes so good

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      Slime
      1 month

      Hes the best doctor! 

      Expand 1 reply
      1. eaglemyles
        9 days

        I go back and forth between them. Smith and Tennant are two of my fave actors anyway and they're such great doctors. I think 11 has the better writing, 10 pulls you at the heart more but Smith had this way about him where he was the youngest doctor but had a way of truly portraying an ancient doctor and old wisdom

  8. Commenters avatar
    Tate
    1 month

    Im so exited you guys are here already Donnas one of my favorite companions!!

  9. ratanka
    1 month

    i have to say, of all companions i get people like her but donna is BY FAR last place for me ... shes so unbelievable annoying

  10. ratanka
    1 month

    rose best companion ever xD

    also they didnt throw her in they did like 5 things for future episodes hinted in this episode xD

  11. Commenters avatar
    Heidi
    1 month

    you guys are going to love who's playing the new doctor haha

  12. Commenters avatar
    Eduardo
    1 month

    you know, she could have... drove the car to the house and tell the doctor to pick her up there, but nope, screw you mom! lmao

  13. Commenters avatar
    Maggie
    1 month

    The Donna era has started!

  14. Commenters avatar
    Alex
    1 month

    Just wait til they see whos the new current doctor 😂

  15. Commenters avatar
    Dr
    1 month

    Will you guys react to the new season of R&M soon?

  16. Commenters avatar
    Bluhawke
    1 month

    Donna is the best. 

  17. Commenters avatar
    Marcello
    1 month

    Rose will always be my favorite, but as Companions go, Donna is a cool best friend Companion.  Right up there with the Ponds.

  18. casualking21
    1 month

    A Kilo is 2.2 pounds

  19. Commenters avatar
    Fl0uche
    1 month

    Ho gosh finally. Season 4 was the peak of the show ( imo) . Donna was my fav companion.  Every episode was gold!

  20. Commenters avatar
    Will
    1 month

    The laugh I let out when Rose turned around. On a rewatch Rose actually wasn't as great as nostalgia made me think she was but the joke hate is genuinely so funny. Martha will always be my fav of the tenant companions but Donna is absolutely the most fun and entertaining.

  21. Commenters avatar
    103_luna_111
    1 month

    oh man- can't wait for all of this hate on rose to hopefully desipate by the end of this season.... I totally get their POV now having watched the reactions but for real just wait a moment before judging (even if it is jokingly) her when she didn't even say one word (all will be revealed eventually). 

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      itsbumbs
      1 month

      No

  22. kalakh
    1 month

    Best Companion has entered the chat. 

    According to Catherine Tate, the mime scene was entirely adlibbed. The script only said Donna and the Doctor notice each other through the windows, and when she asked the director how he thought that should go, he effectively shrugged and told them to make something up.

  23. Commenters avatar
    Jordan
    1 month

    it's weird when they get science stuff half right.  Lipase are the class of enzymes that catalyze fats, but they are proteins themselves

  24. Commenters avatar
    Ryan
    1 month

    I'm starting to suspect they don't actually hate rose as much as they say they do......

    Expand 1 reply
    1. Commenters avatar
      Quin
      1 month

      I mean, Ruff always said he liked her by the end of season 2. It seems like Brie (if that's how her name's spelled) genuinely hates her, because she can't resist complaining about her every time she's on screen, but I think everyone else just leans into the hate as a joke to make fun of commenters for getting made at them criticizing her. That's kind of a trend with them. Whenever comments criticize or get mad at them, they just insult the commenters and lean into whatever they were mad about. Sometimes it's pretty warranted, but other times it kind of just seems like bullying.

Recommended

Patreon Join Our Patreon